Weblog <ahref

Weinberger, Falkvinge, Amamou: video speeches @ <ahref Foundation

On 11 november 2011, during the Italian edition of the Internet Governance Forum, Trento also hosted the roundtable "Internet and Freedom". The event focused on the strategic role of new technologies in the recent protest wave that spread across world, from the Arab Spring to the Indignados and Occupy movements in Western countries. Also discussed were the threats to Internet freedom currently pursued non only by authoritarian governments but also by those countries that call themselves evolved democracies, such as the Italian case.

David Weinberger, Slim Amamou and Rick Falkvinge took part in the event, chaired by Luca De Biase. A report about that discussion is available on the website of IGF Italia 2011. In the evening, the same three speakers held a “lectio magistralis” at the <ahref Foundation headquarters. Now these videos are also available online.

Slim Amamou

Rick Falkvinge

David Weinberger


Jan 30, 2012 05:45 PM

Web goes on strike!

On January 18th, 2012 the internet is going on strike to stop the web censorship bills in Congress!

Joi Ito, executive director of the MIT Media Lab and member of <ahref’s review committee, posted a blog post co-authored with Ethan Zuckerman taking a position against SOPA and PIPA.

Why we need to stop SOPA and PIPA

I just posted a blog post on the MIT Media Lab blog officially taking a position against SOPA and PIPA. This is a longer blog post co-authored with Ethan Zuckerman describing the issue in more detail.

SOPA - the Stop Online Piracy Act - and a sister bill, PIPA - the Protect IP Act - seek to minimize the dissemination of copyrighted material online by targeting sites that promote and enable the sharing of copyright-protected material, like The Pirate Bay. While this goal may be laudable, entrepreneurs, legal scholars and free speech activists are worried about the consequences of these bills for the architecture of the Internet. At the MIT Media Lab, we share those concerns, and we oppose SOPA and PIPA as threats to innovation on the Internet.

To limit access to rogue sites, SOPA and PIPA would:

- supersede the "notice and takedown" method of policing for copyrighted material on Internet services and require service providers to police content uploaded by users or prevent users from uploading copyrighted content
- require Internet Service Providers to change their DNS servers and block resolution of the domain names of websites in other countries that host illegal copies of content
- require search engines to modify their search results to exclude foreign websites that illegally host copyrighted material
- order payment processors like PayPal and ad services like Google AdSense to cease doing business with foreign websites that illegally host copyrighted content

Major internet companies, including Google, Facebook, Twitter and others, oppose SOPA and PIPA because it changes the liability rules around copyright infringement. Under the Digital Millenium Copyright Act of 1998, companies are protected from charges of "contributory infringement" on content uploaded by users, so long as the company follows a procedure and remove infringing content when an alert process is followed. SOPA substantially alters this system, and internet companies worry that without protection from contributory infringement, user-generated content sites like YouTube and Twitter would not have come into existence. The burden of reviewing user-submitted content - every blog post, every video, every image - would be impossible for a company to manage, and companies would have likely stuck with the Web 1.0 model of publishing edited, vetted content instead of moving to a Web 2.0 model where users create the content. Several internet companies took out a full-page ad in the New York Times to express their concerns about SOPA and PIPA.

Free speech advocates, like the Electronic Frontier Foundation, worry that SOPA may provide powerful new tools to silence online speech. Confronted with uncomfortable political speech, repressive governments often seek to silence dissent by reporting content as defamatory, slanderous or copyright infringing, hoping the companies hosting the speech will remove the content. SOPA accelerates the process of copyright removal, with a mechanism that permits copyright holders to obtain court orders against sites hosting copyrighted materials and have those sites rapidly blocked. Scholars of online censorship, like Rebecca MacKinnon at the New America Foundation, worry that SOPA may be popular with the Chinese government as with the copyright holders who are lobbying for the bill.

US law already permits the seizure of domestic domain names that are used for piracy, and the US seized 150 domains in November. SOPA is an attempt to enforce copyright provisions across international borders by prohibiting American internet users from accessing certain foreign websites, like The Pirate Bay. In effect, it would create a firewall to prevent users from accessing prohibited intellectual property, much as China's "great firewall" limits access to politically sensitive information.

Harvard legal scholar Lawrence Tribe believes that SOPA is likely unconstitutional, as it can remove constitutionally protected speech without a hearing, a form of "prior restraint". In a memo sent to members of Congress, he points out that SOPA proposes a system where a single instance of prohibited material could lead to the blocking of thousands of unrelated pieces of content.

Internet experts have observed that, beyond being dangerous to innovation, harmful to speech and potentially unconstitutional, SOPA and PIPA are unlikely to work. Countries that block access to prohibited websites by altering the domain name system - as Vietnam does in blocking access to Facebook - find that millions of users are able to circumvent this form of censorship. Millions of Vietnamese users have become Facebook users by entering that site's IP address into their browsers, or configuring their computers to use an uncensored DNS server. It's likely that dedicated US users of The Pirate Bay and other sites will do likewise. Effectively blocking access to sites like The Pirate Bay might require US ISPs to install powerful and expensive "deep packet inspection" software, a cost that would inevitably be passed onto their users.

The progress of the bills was slowed in late 2011 by widespread online activism opposing SOPA and PIPA. Hearings are likely to resume early in 2012, and opponents of the bills are facing off against organized lobbying campaigns by the music and film industries who support the legislation. On November 16, 2011, participatory media company Tumblr took strong online action against SOPA, redirecting requests for content on the site to a page that urged users to call US representatives and oppose the bill - their daylong campaign generated more than 87,000 calls to Congress. Internet community site Reddit plans a site-wide "blackout" on January 18th to inform users of the potential harms of SOPA and PIPA. Wikipedia is considering doing the same.

In the spirit of these protests, the MIT Media Lab has linked this blogpost to all our site pages, encouraging anyone interested in the work we do to learn more about SOPA and PIPA. More information and resources follow below. We believe that SOPA and PIPA would make it harder for Media Lab students, researchers and faculty to do what we do best: create innovative technologies that anticipate the future by creating it. We hope you'll join with us in opposing these bills and, if you are a US citizen, in letting your representatives know your concerns about this legislation.

- Joi Ito, director, MIT Media Lab

Selected resources on SOPA and PIPA

Liz Dwyer, "Why SOPA Could Kill the Open Educational Resource Movement", Good Magazine

Julian Sanchez, "SOPA: An Architecture for Censorship", Cato Institute

Dan Rowinsky, "What You Need to Know about SOPA in 2012", ReadWriteWeb

"Internet Blacklist Legislation", Electronic Frontier Foundation, EFF's email campaign against the legislation and EFF guide to meeting with your representatives.

Jan 17, 2012 09:20 AM

White Paper on Social Innovation

A white paper on “How to design, develop and grow social innovation” is now available in Italian. Produced by NESTA (National Endowment for Science Technology and the Arts), a UK Government think-thank, the paper is rooted in a detailed observation of current social mechanisms and provides practical solutions to global socio-economic issues by encouraging citizen participation.

Here 'social innovation' is defined as a bottom-up and spontaneous phenomenon that is quickly filling the social gap left open by the failure of old dogma and structures. In turn, this approach pushes anybody toward a broad application of personal resources and ad-hoc strategies in any field and with a global perspective: from the reduction of CO2 emissions to the battle against poverty to the pursuing of universal health care policies.

The economic model envisioned by social innovation is based on a combination of loose networks running on new technologies and the strong presence of human resources. Instead of passive consumers simply being prey to marketing strategies, we have groups of skilled users ready to get involved in designing and marketing products. Aiming at a re-definition of social assets and dynamics, this approach takes full advantage of today’s networking and collaborative practices – producing effective and actual solutions based on both personal culture and collective imagination.

Co-authored by marketing expert Alex Giordano and social scholar Adam Arvidsson, the white paper is divided into three main sections:
- “Innovation process:” a collection of useful ideas and tips to get on track with innovation development;
- “Key institutions:” roles and purposes of various organizations leading to innovation;
- “Conclusion”: an overview of current conditions fostering or preventing the success of social innovation.

The full PDF white paper can be downloaded here, with updates on various case studies published on the Societing.org blog

Jan 02, 2012 03:50 PM
Posts
We can rebuild politics starting from civic media
Google decides who we are
Speaking of democracy, 2,400 years after Plato
Towards civic intelligence
The value of relationships
Diary of the <ahref Foundation’s Educational Week in London
The Fundamental Principles of the Internet
Creative economy and digital commons
Innovation and economic crisis: Ezio Andreta at Trento’s Festival of Economics
Art contest for “La ricerca come mestiere” story
Innovation and development: <ahref at Festival of Economics
Facebookumentario: Italy's history as told by Facebook users
"The way of working" at Tedx Napoli
<Ahref Foundation @ International Journalism Festival
Massimo Banzi talks about Arduino
A collaborative journalism project to overcome prejudices
IGF Italia 2011 video sessions: Internet Freedom and netizen participation
Timu on Italian TV network "la7"
Weinberger, Falkvinge, Amamou: video speeches @ <ahref Foundation
Web goes on strike!
White Paper on Social Innovation
Wall to wall. In Avellino a test of brotherhood, Italian style.
Journalism in the networking age
From Naples’ Sanità District to Trento, a journey filled with 12 stories
Technologies as useful beings for human beings
Timu @ ItaliaCampania: fostering citizen involvement and direct participation to reverse the current trend
‘Privacy traders’: learning about privacy while playing
IGF Italy: The Net belongs to all of us
Discrimination against gay people is the ‘next wall to fall’
Tales from the catacombs
The Italian meeting of the Internet Governance Forum
Summer School: Data journalism and Infographics
School dropout rates & In-Contro project in Rome
1st Digital Agenda Assembly for Europe
DjangoCon 2011 @Amsterdam
Rediscovering the value of the public good
Off-the-book employment and the black economy
<ahref barcamp: enough with garbage, more social innovation
Joichi Ito is the new MIT Media Lab Director
Propublica wins the Pulitzer award again in 2011
TIMU: the meaning of a name
Welcome to the official blog of the Ahref Foundation!
Searching the quality of information on the Internet
© 2012 Fondazione <ahref | Sede legale: Vicolo Dallapiccola 12 - 38122 Trento - Italy | P. IVA 02178080228 Creative Commons License